REF Update
The publication of the final and updated REF guidance should come as little surprise. It is comforting to see that there has been an attempt to streamline definitions across panels.
Specifically, in the Engagement and Impact guidance, we learn that the continuity with REF 2021 is maintained with some now confirmed small(ish) updates, principally: Reduction to the minimum number of ICS for those in the smallest units of assessment, i.e. one for those with 9.99 FTE or fewer (with the encouragement of still submitting two ICS); the new ‘encouragement’ to describe engagement strategies and responsible practices (including guidance on how this is to be done in the narratives and its respective assessment criteria, particularly what responsible practices are, importantly, these remain encouraged rather than mandatory elements, and do not constitute additional assessment criteria in their own right); further guidance on how impact will be assessed against our quintessential reach and significance criteria; confirmation of the removal of the previous 2-star quality threshold for underpinning research, potentially broadening the range of research contributions that can support an eligible impact case study.
Other changes include the requirement of explaining how the ICS relate to the submitting UOA, within the SPRE statement; confirmation of the eligibility period for impact, 1 August 2020 to 31 July 2028, and requirements for continued case studies; confirmation that underpinning research must have first been brought into the public domain between 1 January 2008 and 31 December 2028 , or, in the case of confidential outputs, lodged with the relevant body during that period.
There is also an expansion on what counts as eligible underpinning research, which may now include research undertaken by unpaid staff, subject to specific eligibility conditions; further guidance on what aggregated ICS submissions require; provisions for changes of research units, in particular those that were absorbed into different ones through mergers for example, including the deadlines of 30 June 2028 by which the submitting HEI must seek prior agreement from the relevant UK funding body, through the REF team; and further guidance with examples by which research can underpin impacts. Of particular relevance here is the explicit recognition that the relationship between underpinning research and impact need not be direct or linear, provided that the research has made a distinct and material contribution to the impact claimed. This offers greater clarity on the diversity of pathways through which research can generate impact.
Further updates include some provisions for how the submission template and contextual information must be prepared in terms of how to package the information and where; word lengths; details of the staff conducting the underpinning research; optional details of contributors to impact; how to deal with references and access to them; confirmation of the old maxim that reviewers will not be following URLs (if the claim isn’t adequately explained in your narrative, don’t expect a URL to do the work for you); slightly more clarity on how to deal with corroborating sources of impact; confirmation that corroborating evidence can be submitted in any language; and the requirement to clarify which corroborating evidence is provided upfront and which (if any) is retained by the institution (in case of audit).
One particular update should assuage our collective impact minds for we now get clarity on a hard maximum of 2,200 words for the combined total between summary of the impact (suggested 100), underpinning body of research (suggested 600) and details of the impact, for which I’ll let you do the math. Naturally this is a maximum, so please keep it within it, folk!
We also learned that graphics, charts and diagrams will not count towards this limit (you must alt-text -using the tools within Word- for panellists using screen readers!) but their descriptions do count, the main message is use them wisely! Those with very hush hush impacts will still have a revamped provision for submitting ICS with security clearance.
Ultimately, REF 2029 does not appear to be reinventing the impact wheel, but giving us better tread, improved grip, shinier alloys and, hopefully, a comfier ride! The emphasis remains firmly on demonstrating the reach and significance of impact arising from eligible research, but with some welcome recognition that research contributions, engagement practices and pathways to impact are not always straightforward or linear.
For institutions, the challenge remains much the same: identifying compelling impacts, demonstrating credible links to underpinning research and, crucially, assembling robust evidence. The refinements may be relatively modest, but their implications for how we develop, articulate and evidence impact case studies should not be underestimated.
Responses (0)
No responses yet. Yours would be the first.